29 Mar 2010
Maziar Bahari was imprisoned by the Iranian regime for attempting to report on 2009’s disputed election. He describes his ordeal, and suggests what can be done to help journalists jailed by the Islamic Republic
Being a journalist in Iran is one of the most insecure jobs in a country run by one of the most insecure governments in the world. The Islamic Republic has made journalists its prime target. More than a hundred journalists have been arrested since the disputed presidential elections last summer. It’s very difficult to put a precise figure to the number in prison because it’s been a revolving door. They arrest a group of journalists one day and they let others go the next day. The government is trying hard to prove that it is in control and in charge of the lives of each and every citizen.
In the age of the Internet and satellite television the Iranian government is trying hard to change the tide of history. It wants to take Iran back to the era of shortwave radio and terrestrial television, media that it could easily censor and control. A wise government would listen to the voices of its own people. The Iranian government is shooting the messenger.
“You should not break a mirror because it shows your faults. You should change yourself,” goes a Persian saying. By breaking the mirror the Islamic Republic is losing its legitimacy as a religious government and a government chosen by the people. The actions of the government of Iran are far from Islamic principles of fairness and kindness. Since last June, the government has also been ignoring the people’s peaceful demands for reforms within the framework of the regime.
In fact the Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Khamenei has decided to do away with all democratic pretensions and establish a militarised dictatorship with the help of the Revolutionary Guards. It is an attempt which will ultimately be defeated by the Iranian people. The current Khamenei/Guards project may take a few years or even decades to fail but the Iranian government will finally relent and accept the demands of the Iranian people for democracy, human rights and freedom of expression.
How did we get here?
After the victory of the popular Islamic Revolution in 1979, the new government managed to maintain a certain level of legitimacy. The traditional religious masses supported the government. While the government stifled many voices of dissent it allowed many reformist newspapers, opposition activists, human rights lawyers and journalists to survive and continue criticizing the government with a certain degree of impunity.
The regime did so because the gap between the educated elite and the traditional religious masses was so wide that the government did not feel really threatened by the opposition to its ineffective and authoritarian governance. The opposition had very little influence on the thinking and actions of the people. In fact when the mouthpieces of the government ridiculed the opposition for being elitist, they were telling the truth.
The Digital Age, the Dawn of a New Era
In the pre-internet era, the increasingly educated Iranians did not have a chance to communicate with the outside world or even with each other.
Internet and satellite television brought the knowledge that was in the monopoly of a selected group of western educated elite to a greater number of Iranians. The gap between the elite and the masses was quickly disappearing. And that frightened the government.
Fighting the Future
The protest of millions of people against Ahmadinejad’s re-election in June 2009 was a clear manifestation of this narrowing gap. I was on the streets of Tehran during those days. The demonstrators were not all secular, educated, westernised individuals. They were factory workers, housewives and farmers.
In the absence of any clear vision for the future of the country and looking for a quick fix the government chose to blame the media for stirring people. The government particularly tried to incriminate Western media for trying to create a velvet revolution such those in Czechoslovakia, Ukraine and Georgia in the past. After the June 2009 presidential elections the takeover of the government by the Guards gained a new momentum. They took charge of all the cultural activities in the country as well as the intelligence apparatus. The Guards started doing what they do best: suppression dissent through violence.
My Experience
The Guards arrested me nine days after the election. My interrogator told me, “There is no difference between culture, journalism and intelligence.” He said, “You gather and report information. That is exactly what a spy does.”
For 118 days in 2009 I witnessed an ignorant confused regime trying to fight its own people through sheer paranoia. During those 118 days I heard (because I was mostly blindfolded) so many ridiculous ideas and outlandish interpretations of what is going on in the world by my interrogators that at the end nothing surprised me.
For some reason or another, my interrogator had a fascination with New Jersey. I’m not sure why, I never managed to ask him why, but to him, New Jersey sounded like paradise on earth. He maybe was a big fan of the Sopranos or Jersey Shore, I don’t know, but he thought that whatever happens to people in paradise, including eating the forbidden fruit, copulating with as many men and women as you want, orgies and drinking alcohol was happening in New Jersey. He was upset that I had been in New Jersey, and he had never been. So I was not only a spy, I was a spy that had been to New Jersey.
Of course the memory of those days is funny in hindsight. When you are in a dark interrogation room and you’re blindfolded and you’re subjected to beatings and tortures, as I was and as many of my colleagues in Iran are, your interrogator’s ignorance is far from being funny.
What I saw was tantamount to a scene in Martin Scorsese’s Casino, when a man’s head is squeezed to the point of explosion in a vise. The narrowing gap between the masses and the elite is that vise. The regime reacts as thuggish and violently as those mobsters in Scorsese’s Casino.
What the West can do?
I can say these words on this platform because of the support I received from the international community. I was lucky enough to be working for Newsweek. My colleagues went beyond their call of duty and rallied all their contacts in the international media, and among the diplomatic community, to call for my release.
I was also lucky and blessed by the support of organisations like Index on Censorship, Committee to Protect Journalists and Reporters Sans Frontieres who are advocating the situations of the imprisoned journalists or journalists under duress by other countries.
The fact that I was finally freed (albeit on bail) shows that the Iranian government is not as indifferent to negative publicity as it pretends to be. Iran is not North Korea. Iran needs the help of international community to survive. The Iranian government right now is using international satellite technology to send its message of hate. It is using the same broadcasting laws and regulations as the West to have the offices of its foreign broadcasters in different countries. The world community should prevent the Iranian government from benefiting from what it denies its own people. I was really happy about the European community’s decision this week to penalise Iran for jamming satellite transmissions. I hope they follow these new measures with more urgency and vigour than in the past.
Supporting the free flow of information to and from Iran is investing in Iran’s future. It narrows the gap between Iranians and the rest of the world. It is the quickest shortcut to democracy for Iranians.
In the meantime Khamenei and the guards, as well as their stooge Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, will try their best to suffocate the voices of dissent through brute force. Many lives will perish and be lost in the process. There will be periods of silence and days of turbulence. But in the end, as Prophet Mohammad said, “An infidel can rule a nation for a long time. But an oppressor will never succeed in doing so.”
This is a keynote speech given by Maziar Bahari at the Index on Censorship Freedom of Expression Awards on 25 March. To support the campaign for the release of Iranian journalists from prison go to /www.oursocietywillbeafreesociety.org
Source: Index on Censorship
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Mitra Yousefi. Mitra Yousefi said: “THERE IS NO DIFFERENCE BETWEEN JOURNALISM AND INTELLIGENCE”: ۲۹ Mar 2010 Maziar Bahari was imprisoned by the… http://bit.ly/aP2kl6 #iran [...]
[...] “THERE IS NO DIFFERENCE BETWEEN JOURNALISM AND INTELLIGENCE … [...]
If you are freedom denying, tyrannical, murdering regime, then there is no difference between journalism and intelligence, as you turn the best and the brightest within your own society into spies and freedom fighters.
Will anybody be in a position to smell a smoke smell on me?
no letterman would not be pround he want to see the cowboys win instead of loosing all the time
Definitely. Indie is just an icon. That franchise was the last of a dying breed almost. That and Romancing the Stone are some of the last great TRUE adventure movies. Nowadays they turn way too much towards the action part of action-adventure and mostly abandon the adventure part. Thats part of the reason I was initially excited about the Uncharted movie, thinking theyd get back to making a good adventure movie. Looks like theyll mess that up though.
Do you have a spam issue on this website; I also am a blogger, and I was curious about your situation; we have created some nice practices and we are looking to trade solutions with other folks, why not shoot me an email if interested.
Hiya, I’m really glad I have found this info. Today bloggers publish only about gossips and internet and this is really annoying. A good web site with interesting content, that’s what I need. Thank you for keeping this website, I will be visiting it. Do you do newsletters? Can not find it.
Nickyep itll be great when Dirk, Jason, Shawn and all the others get a ring as none of them have one. Love Wade but hate LBJ and hope he only ever wins 0 rings. And I do miss bantering with paul even though we are like the Hatfields vs the McCoys when it comes to Perk and the trade. The Mavs were soft but the Lakers showed up even softer. Actually the Mavs have really toughened up as the end of the season and playoffs started. Getting Chandler was huge for them. Go Cs
I am very unsettled by his Schumann.The Takamitsu was a good opener..
Janet, Thanks so much for sharing this. Im encouraged by answered prayers. Rejoicing with you!
I love your wp theme, exactly where would you obtain it from?
Isaiah 54:5 (asv) tells us, Thy Maker is thy husband; JEHOVAH OF HOSTS (my emphasis) is his name. Here Isaiah provides a twofold glimpse of our Lord-Sabaoth. First, He is our Maker. Second, He is likewise a Husband. This is a picture of God in His Providential Role Lockyer writes: Has death (annulment/divorce) taken your dear partner and provider and are heart and home vacant, and children left fatherless? Take courage, sorrowing one, for the Lord offers to fill that dear ones place with more of His own abiding presence, and be more to you than an earthly husband could be. May you prove Him to be as a husband in your widowhood. (because of death of spouse or marriage)
Nora: Personally, I dont think the general population having access to more fonts is a bad thing. Im of the opinion that if someone is going to make an uneducated font choice, the odds of them choosing a less visually offensive font are better the more options they have. In fact, its the limitation of only having system fonts to choose from that have made some good fonts go bad. Papyrus is a good example. In itself, its not a bad font. But since it became a system font on Windows machines it has been used on every second new-age/health/artistic piece of print or web design out there. The sheer over-use has made it become viewed as a bad in the design communities.
I just added this blog site to my rss reader, excellent stuff. Can’t get enough! I also share that site at Oneview :-)
۷٫ How does this meet me where I am now? There are some things going on with my oldest today. I think he is having anxiety issues. I am sure that most of the reason is that he is far from God and because he is filling his mind with garbage. I know because I see what he watches on Netflix. On my way home from work tonight, when I was tired, I began to despair of his ever coming back to the Lord. But God, being rich in mercy I remembered that I can’t win this battle, but God can and he will as I see at the end of the 2nd verse. This is the battle in my life right now that these verses speak of to my heart. They are so timely and uplifting for me right now. As for him, I think the hounds of heaven are on his heels.
For once, a pianist who recalls this is the Davidsbundtler, not Waldscenen.
We love Prairie Home Companion too. We love all the weekend shows on NPRThis American LifeWait Wait Dont Tell MeYou Bet Your Gardencould go on and on.Never heard any of those old shows.
paulwelcome back. Did you like the name of the book I gave in the above post? Go Cs.and how can a Heat bench that only scored 11 pts in the last game help beat Dallas???
u hit d nail on d head but dont expect the Jay stans to agree wit u,they are coming 4 ur ass,no homo.
I was wondering if you ever considered changing the layout of your site? Its very well written; I love what youve got to say. But maybe you could a little
Not really a dangerous article, achieved it require plenty of time to take into consideration it?
your RSS feed to my MSN Information Reader. In search of ahead to studying extra from you afterward!…
Hi! I’ve been following your weblog for some time now and finally got the bravery to go ahead and give you a shout out from Houston Texas! Just wanted to say keep up the great job!
As a web-site owner I believe the material here is reallyexcellent. I thank you for your hard work. You should keep it up forever! Good Luck.
Did you hear concerning the Scottish drag queen? He wore pants. -Lynn Lavner
Superb post however , I was wanting to know if you could write a litte more on this topic? I’d be very grateful if you could elaborate a little bit further. Cheers!
some truly wonderful info , Glad I observed this.
I just added this weblog to my google reader, excellent stuff. Cannot get enough! I also share that site at Oneview :-)
I thought this was a definitely incredibly superior publish. In principle Let me publish this way also – getting some time and actual effort to manufacture a wonderful article but exactly what can I have faith that I procrastinate alot and also by no means seem to get a thing done.
Admiring the persistence you put into your site and detailed information you present. It’s awesome to come across a blog every once in a while that isn’t the same outdated rehashed material. Great read! I’ve bookmarked your site and I’m including your RSS feeds to my Google account.
Hi, i think that i noticed you visited my web site thus i came to “return the desire”.I’m trying to to find issues to enhance my web site!I guess its adequate to make use of some of your concepts!!
I’m looking for places to buy online. I’m having problems locating sites that do not require a prescription. Do you have any suggestions?
Hola! I’ve been reading your web site “THERE IS NO DIFFERENCE BETWEEN JOURNALISM AND INTELLIGENCE†| Street Journalist for some time finally have the bravery to go ahead and give you an hi out via New Caney Texas! I would like to tell you continue this great work… Furthermore did you hear Tripoli notable tv news just what does one think
Wow, this post was just a few things i wanted. Thank you posting it.
Hi, Great job! This is my first time i visit here. I discovered so numerous fascinating stuff in your website.
I seen a few posts about drugs on your website and I was just looking for a little information. Do you know of anywhere to get the meds online without a prescription? Any info would be appreciated. Thanks alot and I look forward to reading more entries on your site!
Yeah, i agree with what was said in your write-up. Thanks for all the info. and your hard work.
I have to admit that overall Im really impressed utilizing this type of site.It is possible to identify that youre keen about your writing. In case Id your writing ability I enjoy more updates and will also be returning.
I seen a few posts about drugs on your site and I was just looking for a little information. Do you know of anywhere to get the meds online without script? Any information would be appreciated. Thanks alot and I look forward to reading more posts on your site!
Hey there, I think your site might be having browser compatibility issues. When I look at your website in Opera, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other then that, amazing blog!
Yeah actually you will love Bring the fresh, honestly, I also know this system is suited towards your area of interest!
We’re a group of volunteers and opening a new scheme in our community. Your site offered us with valuable info to work on. You’ve done a formidable job and our entire community will be thankful to you.
I like the valuable info you provide in your articles. I’ll bookmark your blog and check again here regularly. I am quite sure I will learn many new stuff right here! Good luck for the next!
Arrewrist jufufduy kisenasediz
Hello webmaster, commenters and everyone else !!! weblog was absolutely wonderful!
Thanks for sharing!
Good website. I was checking constantly this site and I am impressed! Very useful information specially the last part I care for such information much.
Hello there! This is my first visit to your blog! We are a team of volunteers and starting a new project in a community in the same niche. Your blog provided us useful information to work on. You have done a marvellous job!
There’s noticeably a bundle to learn about this. I assume you made sure good factors in features also.