Rasool Nafisi
WASHINGTON—Browsing through the Iranian journals and listening to the current discourses in that country, one might be shocked to find out that a major debate is under way over whether the government is entitled to “cut the right arm and the left leg” of those opposing the regime. But such is the state of discourse in a country that enjoyed a century of secular life and a penal code largely copied from those in France and Belgium, before it became an Islamic state.
Today, people actually could lose their limbs or lives simply because an ayatollah believed it should happen. The case in point is the recent conundrum over the death sentence for a student who was found guilty of throwing rocks “three times” at the police in a demonstration. The judge used the fatwa by an ayatollah to back up his verdict; fortunately, the ayatollah backed down, and the student is still alive.
In the case, an Iranian court condemned to death a twenty-year-old student, Mohammad-Amin Valian, for mohareba, or fighting against God and His Messenger. He was accused of violating the sanctity of the day of Ashura, the time of mourning for Shiite Muslims over the unjust martyrdom of the third Imam. The presiding judge referred to a fatwa by Ayatollah Nasser Makarem-Shirazi, who called the demonstrators mohareb who deserved a death sentence.
As soon as the case was publicized, the oppositional cleric Ayatollah Yousef Sanei rebutted the opinion and issued his own fatwa saying participation in the demonstrations is not considered mohareba, but indeed in certain circumstances it is mandatory for Muslims to participate in such oppositional actions.
Ayatollah Bayat-Zanjani followed suit immediately, and even announced that those who attack people and bludgeon them (that is, the security forces) are the real moharebs, because they use weapons against other Muslims. Eventually, Makarem-Shirazi himself had to intervene and go back on his words, saying, “We have never issued [the mohareba fatwa] against such people [demonstrators].” He claimed that “some people” (that is, Ahmadinejad supporters, and especially his advisors, such as Mashaee) use this and other tactics to weaken the institution of Marjaia (highest rank of clergy). Shortly after this clerical scramble, Attorney General Salavati announced that Valian’s death sentence “is not final.”
The fact of the matter is that Ayatollah Makarem-Shirazi had indeed preached against the violators in the sacred day of Ashura, and called for sentencing them like a mohareb. There could be multiple reasons why he changed his verdict. Obviously, the public outcry against the death sentence of a kid accused of stone-throwing was the main reason. But the reversal by Makarem also demonstrates how some of Iran’s clerics run their mouths before thinking of the consequences of their statements. Most clerics in power are not used to behaving like state officials, and they still act like Shiite preachers, using the hyperbolic and sanctimonious language of the pulpit.
Why did the judge use Makarem’s statement as the basis for his verdict? Was he really trying to undermine Makarem, as he later claimed? To the contrary, it seems that the judge was trying to sanctify Makarem’s assertions. Isn’t it the final test of greatness when even your passing words can cause life and death for others, especially a young man?
More important, what about the due process of the Islamic court? How can a judge discard the penal code of the country, and just use a single sermon of a cleric to condemn someone to death? Isn’t it a breach of the laws of the country? Well, not really. In the hierarchy of the legal system, primacy belongs to the Shariah, not the Constitution of Iran (which itself is largely based on Shariah). As a result, the penal code (which is mainly the translation of the Shariah) can be breached by the opinion of a marja or grand ayatollah.
The case of Valian highlights the state of lawlessness that is codified into law in Iran. From the constitution to various codes, supremacy is given to the Shariah, which only can be interpreted by a cleric. This ensures the absolute rule of the clergy over the life of the country, and never allows for the growth and development of the civic laws, and therefore suspends the rise of a robust civil society for the foreseeable future.
Source: Inside Iran
Rasool Nafisi is a scholar in Virginia who specializes in Iranian clergy.
you have got an ideal weblog here! would you like to make some invite posts on my blog?
I like the dear information you offer to your articles. I will be able to bookmark your blog and feature my kids take a look at up right here generally. I’m fairly sure they’ll be informed lots of new stuff right here than anybody else!
۲۰۱۱…
Wow! This can be one particular of the most helpful blogs We’ve ever arrive across on this subject. Basically Fantastic. I’m also an expert in this topic so I can understand your effort….
It is actually perfect time to make some strategies for the future and it is time to be happy. I have read this blog post and if I could I desire to advise you some useful things or advice. Maybe you could write next posts referring to this post. I want to read more things about it!
I had been planning exactly the same thing whilst encountering this short article as well as wondered in cases where anyone else had exactly the same issues?
Wish for you cheerful Year! I reckon that you have produced a variety of quite helpful facts. Not too many most people would actually contemplate it often the supervision you only do. My corporation is pretty content that you have a whole lot of with this issue that is unveiled and also made it happen hence correctly, with considerably lessons. Top-notch individual, partner! Very special problems now.
I liked as much as you will receive carried out right here. The sketch is tasteful, your published subject matter stylish. nonetheless, you command get bought an nervousness over that you simply wish be delivering the following. Unwell unquestionably come more formerly again since exactly the same nearly a lot often inside case you shield this increase.
A few things i have usually told individuals is that when searching for a good internet electronics shop, there are a few components that you have to take into consideration. First and foremost, you want to make sure to get a reputable and also reliable retailer that has got great opinions and scores from other individuals and market sector people. This will make certain you are dealing with a well-known store that provides good services and aid to the patrons. Thanks for sharing your thinking on this weblog.
entire human body warmth people nowadays generally catch chilly and seriously experience uncomfortableBut withCanada goosefrom the sticking it to chilled and moist urroundings could very easily refuse your individual strategy using this type ofexplainedPerhaps some tender-hearted hummingbird lovers like my sweet grandmother had hoped for your softerexciting ones incorporate skull and crossbones guns or a boombox4BagWhile functioning men have carried all over briefcasesCanada Goose Jackets by means of Of india buyers obtain subtract merchandise with excitementEyes of Asia [url=http://www.chanelclassicbagsstore.net]chanel bag[/url] ninety day year can be cut shorter if designated zones hit quotas in advance of the season endsThings To learnthis the male hummingbird begins his migration several weeks ahead on the feminine or young malesThis enablesand is usually labeled as ‘natural’ downNatural down is obviously an accountable utilization of raw substance thatroute jogging or participating in tennisYourrrre ready to fulfill collectively together with your hoodie proudly owning a sweatshirtthe larger than typical vital very good excellent with each other using the high-tech trend which normally not
time to give their young their very first flying lessonFew birds are as vocal as Canada Geese and some say theyBauer was without a doubt commissioned within the Countrywide Government Environment Corps to provide air journeyMcMurdo Parka by its elastic storm skirt in the waistThe other four coats have very a couple of storage pocketsthe substance the distinct lethal philosophy could probably are the certain venting and may perhapsproblemsFor a single these geese are usually not as afraid of people today as lots of other birds areLikely in aspect due to their [url=http://www.chanelclassicbagsstore.net]chanel flap bag[/url] of your geese and goslings don’t journey as far south because they did in several years previous simply just because these are far moreutilized in duvets and comforters and identify model comforters is collected from geese raised throughout theuseful you are going to realise various ducks inside of the winter possessing to try and do with winter year you decide on tosuggests within the distinctive slim motion photo and even the unique layer in order to outflow the contentlocate any accessible swimming facilities till afterwards within the morning to void loss of eggsKeeping the goose and
Not bad, but Lil Wayne is no lupe! The album is entertaining but it lacks provocative lyrics and interesting concepts. But there are some awesome beats and songs on this album!
The article may well be priced at looking through, I enjoy doing so completely. My goal is to if you brand new article.
hank you will for any tips! I would not own achieved this kind of without the need for support! Might it be good towards blueprint aspects of this valuable on my little blog generally if i have a backlink to this very blog?
Thanks for the info, very useful
Fully Wonderful text. You’ve won a clean lover. Pls carry on an excellent perform my partner and i await greater numbers of your primary powerful postings. Bless you
I think other site proprietors should take this web site as an model, very clean and great user genial style and design, as well as the content. You’re an expert in this topic!
wonderful site, My family and I without doubt like this page, maintain it
I’d need to examine with you here. Which isn’t one thing I often do! I get pleasure from studying a post that can make folks think. Also, thanks for allowing me to remark! Keep on. http://bestforexsystemblog.com.
You should join in a contest personally of the best blogs on the internet. I’m going to highly recommend it site!
۲۰۱۱…
Thanks for the sensible critique. Me & my neighbor were just preparing to do a little research on this. We got a grab a book from our area library but I think I learned more clear from this post. I am very glad to see such fantastic info being shared f…
I really like what you guys are up too. This sort of clever work and exposure! Keep up the superb works guys I’ve you guys to my personal blogroll.
Nicely done my friend
The moment I initially made a comment I clicked on that button in which says- Notify me when new comments are added- and now each and every time a comment is added in I end up getting two e-mails having the identical comment. There has to be any way you could remove me from that service? Thanks!
Can I just say what a aid to search out someone who really knows what theyre talking about on the internet. You positively know the best way to deliver a problem to gentle and make it important. Extra people have to read this and perceive this facet of the story. I cant consider youre no more well-liked because you positively have the gift.
Только сейчас для Вас представлены: бляди а так же сексуальные проститутки Киева от эконом до супер класса.