I heard a lot about an Iranian film, About Elly, and I decided to watch it. This is the general plot as far as I could make it. The film is about three married couples who travel to northern Iran with their children. A young man named Ahmad and a young woman, called Elly, accompany the group on this trip. Ahmad is visiting Iran for a short time, and Elly works in a day care where Sepideh’s daughter attends. Sepideh has invited both Elly and Ahmad so that they meet and hopefully get married.
Elly wants to go back home after a day as planned, but Sepideh prevents her from leaving. Shortly after, Elly disappears. No one knows what happened to Elly, and it turns out that no one knows anything about her, not even her actual name (Elly is a nick name). Sepideh lets on bits and pieces of information that she has been hiding from everyone. For example, Sepideh knew that Elly was engaged and yet invited her to accompany them on this trip to meet a prospective husband. She claims that she insisted that Elly should come on this trip even though Elly wasn’t keen because she wanted to end it with her bothersome fiancé first.
A young man, claiming to be Elly’s brother, appears on the scene. Sepideh suspects that the man is in fact Elly’s fiancé who accidentally finds out something about the arrangement on the trip. The group decides to tell the man that no one knew the truth about Elly’s engagement. Sepideh insists that she cannot keep the truth from the man as this would ruin Elly’s reputation. At the end, she goes on with the group’s decision to keep her prior knowledge of Elly’s engagement from the man.
In the meantime, the police find the body of a drowned woman. The fiancé confirms the identity of the young woman, refuses to call Elly’s family, takes away Elly’s bag and phone, and leaves.
The effect of a young girl’s disappearance on others’ lives is a highly explored subject in both film and literature. Two distinct examples that come to my mind are stories by two famous Canadian writers. In “Death by Landscape”, Atwood uses the disappearance of a young girl in a camping trip to explore landscape and its place in Canadian psyche and identity. The girl’s body is never found; she vanishes into the landscape. The young girl’s unresolved fate changes the lives of people who came in contact with her. Atwood provides no distinct resolution but many clues and motives for characters’ behaviours as well as the Canadian landscape with its ever present menace.
In “Open Secrets”, Alice Munro uses the disappearance of a young girl in a camping trip to explore hidden secrets in two married couples’ lives. After the young girl disappears, a couple visits an old lawyer and his young wife to seek the lawyer’s advice. They want to know what to do with the information they have about the events of the day of the disappearance of the girl. The woman, married to a semi-retarded man, reveals information that would exclude her husband as a suspect in the disappearance.
The lawyer advises them to talk to the police, but they do not. There are clues in the story to suggest the woman may be withholding information, and why she may be doing that. The old lawyer’s wife keeps her perceived knowledge of the identity of the girl’s killer to herself. Otherwise, she has to reveal her own humiliating secret about her husband’s sexual molestation of her.
The girl’s body is never found just as the secrets in married couples’ lives. Munro provides no distinct resolution, but strong clues as well as motives for the characters’ behaviours. We may wish they behaved differently, but we understand why they behave the way they do.
I hope it is clear why I brought these two examples while examining “About Elly”. The main line of plot in all three is very similar: the disappearance of a young girl reveals information about those around her. The huge difference is that in “About Elly”, the only thing revealed is a huge confusion on the film’s part.
No meaningful motivation or reason is provided for the main character’s behaviour. Sepideh knows that Elly is engaged, and that she does not want to meet Ahmad before she breaks off her engagement. Yet, she relentlessly pursued Elly to meet Ahmad while keeping Elly’s engagement from Ahmad. Why is Sepideh so keen on Elly and Ahmad getting together? OK, Ahmad, her friend, asked her to find him a wife. Is there a shortage of single girls who want to marry someone abroad and leave Iran? Not that I know of. So, why does she have to pursue this particular engaged, granted unhappily, girl? And this is all more confusing as Sepideh does not even know Elly’s full name!
None of these makes any sense. First she hides pieces of information such as Elly’s engagement from Ahmad, the prospective suitor, and her own husband, and everyone else. Then suddenly she cannot hide one single fact (that she knew Elly was engaged) from a man she has just met (the alleged fiancé). Why does Sepideh, who comfortably keeps everything from everyone, has so much difficulty keeping something from Elly’s fiancé? Her reasoning is as meaningless as her overall behaviour: to save Elly’s face in the eyes of her fiance.
The viewer does not know anything about Sepideh except that she is obsessed with matching Elly and Ahmad, and she keeps lying to everyone. Where does that leave the viewer? What conclusion can be drawn, if any? It has been suggested that the films reveals moral conflicts in the Iranian middle class, that we (Iranians) lie all the time, … I think the film fails to raise any valid point or reasonable conclusion.
Knowing that people lie or keep things from one another is not a huge revelation unless a specific person, say one who is known never to lie, under specific circumstances lies. Then we are taken into a different realm as in Miller’s “The Crucible”. In “About Elly” we are faced with a woman who keeps lying for no apparent reason except when her lie may save herself and those around her from some perceived problem. Then she insists that she has to tell the truth, but she never does.
Then there are so many details that do not make sense. How could the police let the alleged fiancé to identify Elly? Should they not call Elly’s family just to check whether this man is Elly’s fiancé? By then, everyone seems to have Elly’s home phone number; so why let a perfect stranger, as far as the police are concerned, identify another perfect stranger? Why is everyone so sure that this man, first claiming to be Elly’s brother, is her fiancé? Why is he so keen to phone someone in Tehran first but then he does not bother to call Elly’s family? Why is he so keen that the group does not bring in the police? Why does he take Elly’s bag if he is not going to her family?
These missing pieces do not transform the film into a mystery but a poorly constructed film. The screen, intentionally or inadvertently, builds upon a very familiar plot but fails in developing into a sound structure and in ending with possible intriguing outcomes. Something both Atwood and Munro have succeeded in brilliantly.
by msabaye
Source:Iranian.com
This is a excellent weblog, could you be interested in going through an interview concerning just how you produced it? If so e-mail me personally!
I feel this is among the most vital info for me. And i am glad reading your write-up. But need to remark on few common issues, The web site style is fantastic, the articles is really nice : D. Excellent job, cheers
I should examine with you here, which is not one thing I usually do! I take pleasure in reading a blog that can make people think. Also, thanks for allowing me to comment!
The best sites……
[...] Wonderful story, believed we can easily put together two or three unrelated data, nevertheless seriously worth taking a look, whoa did one learn about Mid East seems to have more problems as well [...]…
Thank you for the sensible critique. Me & my neighbor were just preparing to do a little research on this. We got a grab a book from our area library but I think I learned more from this post. I am very glad to see such fantastic information being shared freely out there.
I not to mention my guys have already been reading through the nice things on the blog while at once got a horrible suspicion I never expressed respect to the website owner for those techniques. The people are actually as a consequence glad to see all of them and now have honestly been enjoying those things. Thanks for turning out to be very kind and for selecting this form of marvelous subject areas most people are really needing to discover. My personal honest apologies for not expressing appreciation to you earlier.
Recent Additions……
[...] I’d personally tried over a few blogs just for fresh ideas and I did [...]…
This is absolutely gold. I was not expecting that I’d get so much out of reading your write up! You’ve just earned yourself a returning visitor :)
Hello! I just would like to give a huge thumbs up for the great info you have here on this post. I will be coming back to your blog for more soon.
I do like the way you have presented this specific difficulty plus it does indeed present us some fodder for thought. On the other hand, because of what precisely I have experienced, I simply just wish when the feedback pack on that folks keep on issue and in no way start upon a tirade regarding the news of the day. Anyway, thank you for this superb point and though I can not concur with the idea in totality, I respect the standpoint.
I got what you intend, saved to favorites , really decent internet web site .
Between me and my husband we’ve owned more MP3 players over the years than I can count, including Sansas, iRivers, iPods (classic & touch), the Ibiza Rhapsody, etc. But, the last few years I’ve settled down to one line of players. Why? Because I was happy to discover how well-designed and fun to use the underappreciated (and widely mocked) Zunes are.
if this post was likened to a flavor of yogurt, what flavor would it be? Banana, I feel.
How in the heck did they get so many danged Indies on this survey, and so few Dems? Either lightning struck (metaphorically), or there was some chicanery with the polling, or suddenly, there are far fewer Dems in MA! They haven’t become Pubs, but they are abandoning the Dems in MASSIVE numbers!
I really am fond of your article and would like to know if I give a link back to your website if I can get your article on one of my site?
As a Newbie, I am always searching online for articles that can help me get further ahead.
This is exactly what I was looking for, in order to prove a debate. Thanks for posting. I sincerely appreciate it (just won £۵۰) Great :)
Neat blog! Is your theme custom made or did you download it from somewhere? A theme like yours with a few simple tweeks would really make my blog shine. Please let me know where you got your theme. Cheers
I was reading many of your content on this website and I conceive this internet site is really informative ! Keep on putting up.
This may not be the most beneficial place to request this, but I am trying to find a pest control business inside the pittsburgh area and have no method to find out who’s the very best. I discovered this company that is truly close to me and wished to see if any individual has any evaluations on them. Spectrum Pest Control, 3058 West Liberty Avenue, Dormont, PA 15216 – (412) 446-2802
Fantastic blog! Great!
This would be the correct weblog for anybody who wishes to discover this subject. You realize an excellent deal of its almost tough to argue along with you (not too When i would want…HaHa). You truly put a brand new spin utilizing a topic thats been written about for decades. Wonderful stuff, just amazing!
This post about how to embed a YouTube video code is truly valuable designed for fresh internet access viewers. Fastidious work, keep it up.
You can definitely see your skills within the work you write. The arena hopes for even more passionate writers such as you who are not afraid to say how they believe. All the time follow your heart. “If you feel yourself falling, let go and glide.” by Steffen Francisco.
F*ckin’ awesome things here. I am very glad to see your article. Thanks a lot and i’m looking forward to contact you. Will you kindly drop me a e-mail?
I’m not sure where you’re getting your information, but good topic. I needs to spend some time learning more or understanding more. Thanks for wonderful information I was looking for this information for my mission.
It is really a nice and helpful piece of info. I am glad that you shared this useful information with us. Please keep us up to date like this. Thank you for sharing.
that you are genuinely variety a person admin your running a blog is astounding i continually check your webpage i am positive you will probably be the top
I found so many interesting stuff in your blog especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the enjoyment here! keep up the good work.
This really answered my problem, thank you!
http://realmillenium.com.my/jcow/index.php?p=blogs/viewstory/28317
Hi there! I understand this is sort of off-topic but I needed to ask. Does running a well-established blog like yours require a lot of work? I am completely new to writing a blog however I do write in my diary daily. I’d like to start a blog so I can share my personal experience and thoughts online. Please let me know if you have any kind of suggestions or tips for new aspiring blog owners. Appreciate it!
I have observed that over the course of developing a relationship with real estate entrepreneurs, you’ll be able to get them to understand that, in every real estate contract, a commission is paid. Finally, FSBO sellers tend not to “save” the commission. Rather, they fight to earn the commission through doing a good agent’s job. In this, they spend their money in addition to time to carry out, as best they can, the jobs of an agent. Those obligations include revealing the home through marketing, delivering the home to buyers, creating a sense of buyer desperation in order to prompt an offer, arranging home inspections, managing qualification investigations with the loan company, supervising repairs, and facilitating the closing.
Hands down, Apple’s app store wins by a mile. It’s a huge selection of all sorts of apps vs a rather sad selection of a handful for Zune. Microsoft has plans, especially in the realm of games, but I’m not sure I’d want to bet on the future if this aspect is important to you. The iPod is a much better choice in that case.
wonderful post, very informative. I wonder why the other specialists of this sector don’t notice this. You should continue your writing. I am confident, you’ve a huge readers’ base already!
Hey! Do you use Twitter? I’d like to follow you if that would be okay. I’m definitely enjoying your blog and look forward to new posts.
Between me and my husband we’ve owned more MP3 players over the years than I can count, including Sansas, iRivers, iPods (classic & touch), the Ibiza Rhapsody, etc. But, the last few years I’ve settled down to one line of players. Why? Because I was happy to discover how well-designed and fun to use the underappreciated (and widely mocked) Zunes are.
I have observed that online degree is getting well-known because accomplishing your college degree online has developed into a popular selection for many people. A huge number of people have never had a possibility to attend an established college or university however seek the raised earning potential and career advancement that a Bachelor Degree offers. Still other people might have a degree in one discipline but would wish to pursue a thing they now possess an interest in.